By B&I Editors
November 2026
More than two decades after its announcement, the so-called James Ossuary continues to attract publicity as a purported archaeological link to Jesus and his family. The Biblical Archaeology Society has recently republished a discussion first published in 2015, while evangelical apologist Jeremiah J. Johnston has renewed the case for authenticity in his James Ossuary “scorecard”, appealing to paleography, patina studies, name-frequency estimates, and the outcome of the forgery prosecution.
The defensible scholarly summary remains the same: an ancient box, a disputed inscription, and an unestablished identification with Jesus’ family. The antiquity of the box, the authenticity and date of its inscription, and the identification of the people named in it are separate issues and require separate arguments. Johnston acknowledges that the 2012 acquittal of Oded Golan does not establish the authenticity of the box; neither would an ancient inscription, by itself, establish the proposed connection with the family of Jesus.
The ongoing controversy also illustrates broader methodological concerns examined by Robert Rezetko, Mark Elliott, and Kenneth Atkinson in their introduction to Misusing Scripture: What Are Evangelicals Doing with the Bible? (Routledge, 2023): apologetic approaches to biblical scholarship, selective appeals to archaeology, and the transformation of qualified findings into confident public claims about biblical history.
Against this background, we republish Paul V. M. Flesher’s report on the scholarly sessions surrounding the ossuary’s 2002 Toronto exhibition: The Experts and the Ossuary: A Report on the Toronto Sessions about the James Ossuary. His account documents the interplay between expert debate and public promotion at the controversy’s beginnings. Related reading includes his “Observing the Ossuary”, review of Shanks and Witherington’s book, and assessment of the 2012 verdict. Further discussion appears in our collection of essays on the James Ossuary and Temple Tablet and our collection of reports from the Israel Antiquities Authority.
The James ossuary was on display at the Royal Ontario Museum from November 15, 2002 to January 5, 2003. Photo: Wikipedia.
Please provide your full name. Comments are moderated and may be edited to remove inappropriate content or links.